- An off-the-shelf CMMS fixes disorganisation. If your problem is missed services, it will almost certainly do.
- Custom pays off when the software has to talk to your machines, job sheets and invoicing, or when you still keep an Excel file alongside it.
- If you already have one that works, connecting it is often enough.
The short answer
If your problem is disorganisation, off-the-shelf. Missed services, breakdowns with no history, spares that aren’t there. If your problem is that nothing talks to anything, look at custom. Hours someone types in, job sheets recorded twice, costs nobody cross-checks.
Side by side
| Off-the-shelf | Custom | |
|---|---|---|
| Getting started | Quick, if your data is ready. | Slower: it has to be built. |
| Features | Many, used or not. | The ones you need. |
| Your way of working | You adapt. | It adapts to you. |
| Services | By date or typed-in hours. | By the machine’s real hours. |
| Cost | A fee, often per user. | Investment and maintenance. |
| Your data | Check how you take it with you. | Yours, if it’s in writing. |
The sign you’ve outgrown it
There’s a very clear one: you still keep an Excel file alongside it. If you pay for software and what matters lives outside it, you don’t lack training, you lack fit. Other signs:
- Someone types in each machine’s hours by hand, and they’re late.
- Technicians fill in a job sheet and someone else retypes it.
- You know what you spend on maintenance, but not what each asset costs you.
- You work where there’s no coverage and the phone goes blank.
Why real hours matter
A service by date treats a machine that has worked non-stop the same as one that has stood still. One by typed-in hours relies on someone remembering. With telematics connected, the service triggers itself when it’s due. So you don’t miss it, or do it too soon.
Five questions for the supplier
- Can it trigger services from hours read from the machine?
- Does it work on mobile and with no coverage?
- Does it have an API to connect it to my software?
- How do I take all my data with me if I leave?
- What happens to the fee if I grow?
Before choosing, have this
No software fixes data that doesn’t exist. Whatever you choose:
- A list of equipment, with code and location.
- A service plan for each. Start from what the manufacturer says.
- Whatever breakdowns you’ve recorded, even if incomplete.
- One person answerable for it being used. Without that, no software works.
If you also run a spare parts store, see warehouse management software: they often go hand in hand.
The third option: connect
If you already have a CMMS that works, don’t replace it. Often it’s enough for it to receive machine hours and the team’s job sheets. We compare both routes in general in custom or off-the-shelf software. And applied, in custom maintenance software.